Well-water iron and sulfur treatment

What the numbers mean, which treatments fit, and the order that works. Test with a certified lab first.

Enter your well-water numbers

Test with a certified lab first. Use lab results if you have them. Find a certified lab.
A smell only at the hot tap can come from the water heater rather than the well, so test both.
Planning estimates only. Verify your numbers with a certified lab test, and have any installation done by a licensed plumber. Results are estimates, not engineering, plumbing, medical, or legal advice, and no health claims are made. See the terms.

The guide

Iron in well water

Dissolved ("clear-water") iron looks clear from the tap, then turns orange as it meets air and leaves rust-colored stains on fixtures and laundry. It also uses up softener capacity: size with 3 gpg per ppm. Particulate ("red-water") iron is already solid and a sediment filter can catch it.

EPA's secondary guideline is 0.3 ppm for iron and 0.05 ppm for manganese. Source: EPA: Secondary Drinking Water Standards (iron, manganese, pH, odor)

Rotten-egg odor

Hydrogen sulfide gas gives water a rotten-egg smell. Slight odors can often be handled by an air-injection or catalytic filter; strong odors usually need chemical oxidation followed by carbon. If only the hot tap smells, ask a plumber to check the water heater. A lab test for sulfur and bacteria tells you what you are dealing with.

Source: EPA: Private Drinking Water Wells

Comparing the options

ApproachTypical fitNeedsWatch for
Iron-rated softenerUp to ~2 ppm clear-water iron, no sulfurSalt, resin cleanerFouled resin above its rating
Air-injection oxidizing filterIron up to ~7-10 ppm, slight sulfurDrain, power, no chemicalsManganese at low pH; air-bleed upkeep
Catalytic media filterIron plus manganese, sulfurBackwash, sometimes an oxidantMedia rating and pH window
Chemical oxidation + contact tank + filterHigh iron or strong sulfurChemical feed pump, supply of oxidant, carbon afterOngoing chemical handling

Typical manufacturer rating ranges, not guarantees; check each product's spec sheet. Source: EPA: Private Drinking Water Wells

Order matters

  1. pH neutralizer if pH is below 7.0.
  2. Oxidation and iron/sulfur filtration.
  3. Carbon, where an oxidant was used.
  4. Sediment polish (optional).
  5. Softener, sized on hardness once iron is out.

Use the planner above to get this chain from your numbers.

Frequently asked questions

What causes rust stains and a metallic taste in well water?

Dissolved iron that oxidizes on contact with air. A lab test gives the ppm. EPA's secondary guideline for iron is 0.3 ppm, based on staining and taste rather than a health limit.

Why does my water smell like rotten eggs?

Usually hydrogen sulfide gas. If only the hot water smells, the water heater may be involved. A lab test and a plumber can narrow it down.

Can a softener remove iron?

Only a limited amount of clear-water iron (about 2 ppm as a conservative planning figure). Above that, use an oxidizing filter first.

What if the water is clear at first and turns orange?

That is typical of dissolved (clear-water) iron oxidizing after it reaches air. Oxidation and filtration is designed for exactly that.

Do I need to test for bacteria?

EPA recommends private-well owners test at least yearly for total coliform bacteria, nitrate and other basics. Ask a certified lab.

Sources